|
Posted by Curt Welch on August 19, 2008, 2:16 am
> I read an article today in Wired magazine about a plan to get an electric
> car / battery infrastructure going in Israel as a beta test. Somewhere in
> the article it mentioned something like "don't need gears because to go
> faster you just apply more electricity" ... I've seen this same statement
> mentioned in other articles about electric vehicles.
> But is this true?
Yes.
> Would gearing up / gearing down help to preserve the
> battery's power once the vehicle gets rolling - just as gearing up/down
> does for internal combustion engines ? These statements seem a bit
> ignorant ...
> I figure this topic applies just as much to robotics, hence my posting it
> here. JCD
DC motors draw the power needed/used. If you drop the voltage (take you
foot off the "gas") to the level required to maintain your speed, the DC
motor will be drawing exactly what it needs to overcome air resistance and
all the friction effects and nothing more. No energy is wasted as long as
your voltage regulator is not wasting energy (which they all do to some
extent). Gears are mostly needed in cars because internal combustion
engines have very low torque and power and low speeds. Gears are added to
adjust for this fact. DC motors on the other hand have max torque at the
low speed so they have just what is needed. Their max torque is the stall
torque (the torque provided when the motor is not turning at all). Gears
are typically added to DC motors when the max RPM of the motor is higher
than the application needs - so you add gears to increase the torque and
reduce the max RPM delivered (you shift the power curve down to a lower RPM
point). But seldom is there a need to have more than one gear ratio (aka
multiple gears like a car). The only examples I can think of where DC
motors have multiple gears are where the gears are used as a cheap speed
control device. This is, instead of an expensive power control circuit,
they just used gears with no power control other than an on/off switch.
--
Curt Welch http://CurtWelch.Com/
curt@kcwc.com http://NewsReader.Com/
| 
Yahoo! 
Google 
Windows Live 
del.icio.us 
digg 
Netscape 
XML site map
> car / battery infrastructure going in Israel as a beta test. Somewhere in
> the article it mentioned something like "don't need gears because to go
> faster you just apply more electricity" ... I've seen this same statement
> mentioned in other articles about electric vehicles.
> But is this true?